Statistics · Testing · Hard
Two weak results
Two independent experiments test the same null hypothesis, and each gives a p-value of 0.1. Under the null each p-value is uniform on 0 to 1. To combine the two results you ask how likely it is, under the null, that the product of two such independent p-values is 0.01 or less. What is that probability?
a fraction, an expression or a decimal to two significant figures · 5/8 · ln 2 · pi · inf
Answer and solution
Answer
0.0561
Solution
The product of two uniforms is at most c with probability c(1 − ln c), which is far more than c.
P = 0.01 + ∫ from 0.01 to 1 of (0.01/u) du = 0.01 + 0.01 ln 100 = 0.01 × 5.605 = 0.056. Two p-values of 0.1 together are worth a single p-value of about 0.056, not 0.01.
Testing comes up in 5 firms' roundsD. E. Shaw · Two Sigma · Tower Research · +2
These 6 rounds ask this kind of problem live, with follow-ups. Every round on every track is in Premium.