Probability · Conditional and Bayes · Hard
The same number twice
A bag holds three fair dice: one with four sides, one with six and one with eight, each numbered from 1 upwards. A friend takes one die at random and rolls it twice where you cannot see. The friend, who always tells you truthfully whether or not the two rolls matched and tells you nothing else, says that they showed the same number. The friend now rolls the same die a third time. What is the probability that the third roll shows that same number again?
Answer and solution
Answer
61/312 ≈ 0.1955
Solution
Update on the match, which is three halves as likely with four sides as with six, then average the chance of a further match over the three dice.
A match has probability 1/4, 1/6 and 1/8 with the three dice, so they now have probabilities 6/13, 4/13 and 3/13. The third roll matches with probability 6/13 × 1/4 + 4/13 × 1/6 + 3/13 × 1/8 = (36 + 16 + 9) / 312 = 61/312 ≈ 0.20.
Conditional and Bayes comes up in 8 firms' roundsJane Street · Hudson River Trading · Citadel Securities · +5
These 16 rounds ask this kind of problem live, with follow-ups. Every round on every track is in Premium.