Games and decisions · Auctions and information · Medium
Two rivals who shade their bids
You and two rivals each hand in one sealed bid for an item. The highest bid wins and the winner pays their own bid; equal highest bids are settled at random. Each rival's value for the item is drawn independently and uniformly between $0 and $90, and each rival bids two-thirds of their own value. The item is worth $75 to you, and your profit is $75 less your bid if you win and nothing if you lose. What bid, in dollars, maximises your expected profit?
Answer and solution
Answer
50
Solution
Trade the margin when you win against the chance of winning: maximise (value − bid) × probability of beating both rivals.
A bid b up to 60 wins with probability (b/60)². The derivative of (75 − b)b² is 150b − 3b², which is zero at b = 50. That is below 60, so the formula holds, and you bid $50: two-thirds of your value, as the rivals do.
Auctions and information comes up in 2 firms' roundsJane Street · Point72 / Cubist
These 2 rounds ask this kind of problem live, with follow-ups. Every round on every track is in Premium.